Buffy the Vampire Slayer’s first Willow episode is still one of its least popular
I, Robot... You, Jane ranks last in season 1

- September 18, 2026
- Updated: September 30, 2026 at 4:28 PM

Buffy the Vampire Slayer’s “I, Robot… You, Jane” aired on April 28, 1997. It was the show’s first Willow-centered episode, and it still tends to show up on lists of the series’ weakest hours.
The ratings back that up. On IMDb, “I, Robot… You, Jane” sits at 6.6, the lowest score in Buffy the Vampire Slayer season 1. It also lands near the bottom in larger episode rankings, at 142 out of 144 for Vox and 129 for Rolling Stone. The setup, at least on paper, has that very specific 1990s appeal: Willow falls for “Malcolm,” only to discover he’s actually Moloch, a demon turned loose on the internet and later plugged into a robot body. What drags it down is the way it plays out, with corny execution, an awkward tone, dated cyberspace clichés, and a final reveal that’s hard to take seriously.
Going back to early Buffy the Vampire Slayer, “I, Robot… You, Jane” is mostly worth pulling out as a little time capsule of 1990s internet panic, and for the introduction of Jenny Calendar as Rupert Giles’ techno-pagan counterpart and future love interest. Willow, meanwhile, is written far too passively here, especially knowing she later becomes one of the show’s richest characters. You can also already spot the shakier side of the show’s early monster-of-the-week run, before the serialized leap late in season 2, along with some clumsy first attempts at ideas the series would brush up against again: online manipulation, curated identity, and the collision between old knowledge and digital culture. You can find it in Buffy the Vampire Slayer season 1.
Choose Softonic on Google and you'll see more of our articles in Top Stories, AI Overviews and AI Mode.
Emmanuel Pina covers entertainment at Softonic: film, television series and the tangle of platforms you have to search through to find them. He is as interested in the premiere as in the fine print: where something is available, until when, and why it vanishes from a catalogue without warning. He is part of Softonic's editorial team and works daily with AI tools applied to content production.
Latest from Emmanuel Pina
You may also like
NewsDiscord’s new Rust client surfaces: 290MB RAM, 1-second launches
Read more
NewsWhite House network appeared as residential proxy exit, researchers say
Read more
NewsAvengers: Doomsday Jeep ad reveals Latveria: first on-screen look at Doom’s MCU home
Read more
NewsApple confirms $7.5 billion bond sale: orders top $30 billion
Read more
NewsHomeland finds new life on streaming: The Game revival is still unconfirmed
Read more
NewsThe Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time is out now on Switch 2: change this setting first
Read more