News
“You have failed, you should be ashamed of yourselves”: The Green Lantern writer who has hated the HBO Max series with all his heart
Ethan Van Sciver blasted Lanterns for destroying every major character

- October 8, 2026
- Updated: October 8, 2026 at 5:44 PM

After all the controversy surrounding Lanterns, the HBO Max series has finally come to an end, and the reviews have been, to put it generously, mixed. DC fans have gotten angry with Damon Lindelof and Tom King for telling a story their way instead of adapting one of the character’s legendary storylines, and they’re not alone: some of the publisher’s creators have taken up arms against the streaming service for not doing it well enough.
In the darkest night…
Grant Morrison was one of the first to get angry with the series, although gradually he got into it and admitted his mistake. That is something Ethan Van Sciver, artist on the comic-book series, can’t say: he’s watched it week after week and has waited until the end to share his opinion: “You failed”. Then again, what’s he going to say.
“It shouldn’t have been hard to put these characters through the hell you’ve put them through and have them come out better in episode 8, but instead you’ve destroyed them. All of them. Even the Manhunters are diminished by this series. John is a villainous, selfish asshole. Kerry is a monstrously stupid and cowardly murderer, Guy is a coward and Hal… Why did you have to kill him in such an empty and senseless, depressing and sick way?“. It’s not clear to me: so, did you like it or…?
But it doesn’t end there: “There is something deeply wrong with your writers’ room. I can’t believe James Gunn allowed this sick nightmare to sit alongside his fun superhero movies. All of you should be ashamed of this tremendous failure”. At HBO Max they’re considering giving it a second season, but just to be safe, it’d be better not to show it to DC’s creators. For whatever reason, they didn’t like it very much.
Choose Softonic on Google and you'll see more of our articles in Top Stories, AI Overviews and AI Mode.
Editor specializing in pop culture who writes for websites, magazines, books, social networks, scripts, notebooks and napkins if there are no other places to write for you.
Latest from Randy Meeks
- Tom Cruise is up to his neck in work, but that isn’t going to stop us from getting the sequel to one of his biggest hits. With or without him
- All movie lovers love Letterboxd. The question is whether we’ll keep loving it when this giant buys it.
- The sequel to ‘Once Upon a Time in… Hollywood’ already has a new trailer, and David Fincher may improve on Quentin Tarantino
- We weren’t going to be left without ‘John Wick’, but his new movie isn’t what you expected
You may also like
NewsNintendo Switch 2 hits $499: PS5, Xbox and Steam Deck prices are up too
Read more
NewsThe Rings of Power season 3 forges the One Ring at last: Prime Video planned it for years
Read more
NewsClockwork Revolution now targets 2027: the BioShock comparison is real
Read more
NewsGTA 6 on PS5 could unlock early in New Zealand: play up to 13 hours ahead
Read more
NewsStellar Blade Complete Edition is out on Switch 2: Digital Foundry says it’s better than expected
Read more
NewsFortnite reveals Pirate Shop Access odds after backlash: 1 in 137,500
Read more