Tesla Insurance Premiums Skyrocket Amid Rising Repair Costs

Tesla insurance premiums are rising sharply, increasing at more than twice the rate of the overall U.S. auto market.

This trend is largely attributed to soaring repair costs and a troubling uptick in vandalism incidents involving Tesla vehicles.

A recent study by Insurify reveals that the average cost for full coverage insurance in the U.S. has climbed by 10% year-over-year, now sitting at approximately $2,302, up from $2,102.

Vandalism and Repair Prices Drive Up Tesla Insurance Rates

The data, drawn from a staggering 97 million insurance quotes between February 2024 and February 2025, indicates that the premium for the Tesla Model Y has surged nearly 3 times faster than the national average.

This spike underscores the growing concerns over the affordability of insuring electric vehicles, which were already known for their high coverage costs prior to this surge.

While increased instances of vandalism have certainly contributed to these escalating insurance premiums, experts believe the higher cost of repairs plays a more significant role. Tesla vehicles are notoriously expensive to repair, prompting some insurance companies to salvage them rather than pay for repairs after collisions.

Consequently, even as Tesla attempts to alleviate the situation by launching its own body shops to control repair costs, the impact on insurance rates remains minimal thus far.

Despite introducing its own insurance product, the majority of Tesla owners continue to rely on policies from external providers. This growing strain on Tesla vehicle owners highlights the importance of addressing repair costs and vehicle protection, as both continue to influence insurance pricing.

With tariffs looming over the automotive sector, further changes in repair costs could exacerbate these trends in the months ahead, suggesting that the market may need to brace for additional spikes in premiums.