News
FCC commissioner warns of location data threats

- April 4, 2019
- Updated: July 2, 2025 at 5:08 AM


Little did we know, every move we make is being sold for hundreds of dollars.
FCC commissioner Geoffrey Starks wrote in an op-ed piece for the New York Times that wireless companies sell users’ location data, and that the FCC should stop them.
.@nytopinion published my first op-ed today. I argue it is downright dangerous for our wireless carriers to sell our location data to facilitate pay-to-track schemes. And I point out that the FCC’s time to hold wrongdoers accountable may be running out. https://t.co/0wh9MxcxMJ
— Geoffrey Starks (@GeoffreyStarks) April 2, 2019
Who is using our location data?
Last year, the New York Times broke a story about a sheriff using location data to monitor the locations of people in his jurisdiction. Whether or not he had the best intentions, his methods were, at best, against FCC regulations and at worst, immoral.
Although the sheriff was reprimanded for his actions, the question still looms, “Who has access to our locations, and how are they getting it?”
As Starks wrote, even bounty hunters have been using location data to find and locate their targets. “A bounty hunter was able to pay to track a user’s location on a map accurate to within a few feet,” Starks writes.
How to make money selling your personal data
Read NowHow are they getting it?
Our cellphone service providers take location data directly from our phones throughout the day so that we can be contacted. That location data is only supposed to be divulged by our service provider for emergency situations.
We can opt to allow apps like GrubHub or Waze to use our location in order to use their services, but they have to get permission. They also aren’t allowed to sell our personal location data.
Unlike an app, we can’t opt out of allowing our service provider to have access to our location data.
This is an FCC issue
Make no mistake, it is the FCC’s responsibility to handle this problem.
As Starks wrote, “It is unquestionably the FCC’s job to protect consumers and address risks to public safety. Our location information isn’t supposed to be used without our knowledge and consent and no chain of handoffs or contracts can eliminate the wireless company’s obligations.”
The FCC has been investigating this issue, but they have not taken action.
“The FCC must use its authority to protect consumers and promote public safety, and act swiftly and decisively to stop illegal and dangerous pay-to-track practices once and for all,” Starks writes.
Starks went on to say that as a commissioner, he can call for action on this problem. However, he can only do so if the FCC chairman first adds the issue to the FCC’s agenda.
What happens next?
Starks took the right step by writing the piece for the New York Times. His story has only been online for two days, but it already been shared thousands of times across social media. Only time will tell as to how the FCC will respond to the article and the public outcry.
Jacob Yothment is the assistant content editor for Softonic. He's worked in journalism since high school, and has been a fan of all things technology and video games his entire life. He is a 2016 graduate of Purdue University Northwest.
Latest from Jacob Yothment
You may also like
NewsThis weekend you can try one of Obsidian's most acclaimed games from 2025 for free
Read more
NewsAn independent developer has spent 300 hours making the credits for his game because he wants to include everyone
Read more
NewsMatthew Lillard reacts to Quentin Tarantino's negative comments: "I can't hold on to negativity"
Read more
- News
The creators of Silent Hill 2 Remake and Cronos: The New Dawn could be working on the remake of another classic horror game
Read more
- News
The new adaptation of Wuthering Heights has captivated critics
Read more
NewsReduction of video production time: a practical Premiere Pro workflow for marketing teams
Read more